Ryan Murphy, the creative force behind Monsters: The Lyle and Erik Menendez Story, was drawn to the infamous case because of its sensational elements and the media frenzy surrounding it. “I feel like that’s faux outrage. Because if you look at what we do, we give those boys so much airtime to talk about what they claim as their physical abuse. We live in a sort of culture of outrage that a lot of things are knee-jerk, and that’s fine. I’m used to being controversial. It’s not new to me.”
Murphy’s bold approach challenges the audience to reconsider the narrative. By highlighting the brothers’ claims of abuse and questioning the fairness of their second trial, he sparks thought-provoking discussions. He doesn’t just tell a story; he invites us into a dialogue about justice, media influence, and the complexity of human behaviour. It’s not merely a retelling of a crime but a deep dive into the layers that make the case both shocking and thought-provoking.
Monsters: The Lyle and Erik Menendez Story is the second season of the riveting biographical crime drama anthology series Monster, masterfully created by Ryan Murphy and Ian Brennan for Netflix. This season delves into the notorious case of Lyle and Erik Menendez, whose 1996 conviction for the brutal 1989 murders of their parents, José and Kitty Menendez, shocked the nation.
The series meticulously unpacks the complex narrative, exploring not only the heinous crime but also the intricate family dynamics, psychological trauma, and the sensational media coverage that surrounded the trial. Through its compelling storytelling, it aims to provide viewers with a nuanced understanding of the Menendez brothers’ motivations and the subsequent legal battles that captivated the public.
Murphy and Brennan’s keen eye for detail and their ability to humanize even the most controversial figures make this series a profound exploration of crime, punishment, and the often blurred lines between victim and perpetrator.
Ryan Murphy was inspired to create Monsters: The Lyle and Erik Menendez Story to spark conversations about abuse and the criminal justice system. He wanted to bring the Menendez brothers’ case back into the spotlight and encourage discussions about whether their second trial was fair. Murphy believed that revisiting the case could help people talk about the impact of abuse and the complexities of the legal system.
He also aimed to present the story from multiple perspectives, giving a voice to the brothers, their parents, and others involved in the case. By doing so, he hoped to create a more nuanced understanding of the events and the people involved.
Ryan Murphy and his team used a combination of meticulous research and creative storytelling to create the fictional reality in Monsters: The Lyle and Erik Menendez Story.
Murphy and his team conducted thorough research on the Menendez case, including court transcripts, interviews, news articles, and documentaries to ensure they had a comprehensive understanding of the events and the people involved.
While they relied heavily on factual information, they also used creative storytelling techniques to fill in the gaps and enhance the narrative. This included imagining conversations and emotional moments that may not have been documented, but were plausible within the context of the story.
In creating the fictional reality for the series, Murphy and his team often needed to fill in gaps where specific details were unavailable. This is where creative storytelling came into play.
They crafted dialogues and interactions that might not have been recorded or reported, but were plausible given the context and known behavior of the characters. These imagined conversations helped to add depth and realism to the narrative. When certain historical details were missing or unclear, Murphy’s team used plausible scenarios to bridge these gaps. This helped to maintain a continuous and engaging storyline while staying true to the essence of the real events.
The series included emotional moments that portrayed the inner struggles and psychological turmoil of the characters. While these moments might not have been explicitly documented, they were rooted in the characters’ experiences and the overall narrative arc. Understanding the motivations behind the actions of Lyle and Erik Menendez, as well as their parents, was crucial. The creators used creative storytelling to explore these motivations, providing viewers with a deeper insight into the characters’ minds and emotions.
They also employed visual and symbolic elements to convey the emotional and psychological states of the characters. This included using specific lighting, colors, and set designs to reflect the mood and themes of different scenes.
While the series aimed to be as accurate as possible, it also embraced the flexibility of fiction to create a compelling and cohesive narrative. This balance between fact and fiction allowed the creators to tell a more complete and engaging story.
By using these creative techniques, Ryan Murphy and his team were able to enhance the narrative and provide a deeper, more immersive experience for viewers. This approach not only made the series more engaging but also allowed it to explore the complex emotions and motivations of the characters involved in the Menendez case.
A key focus was on developing the characters of Lyle, Erik, and their parents, José and Kitty Menendez.
The team delved into the psychological and emotional aspects of these individuals, exploring their motivations, fears, and relationships. This helped to humanize the characters and provide a deeper understanding of their actions.
The series explored the brothers’ motivations, particularly their claims of enduring years of abuse. By delving into their fears and experiences, the creators aimed to provide a deeper understanding of why they might have committed such a heinous crime. The complex relationship between the brothers was a focal point. Their bond, forged through shared trauma, and their loyalty to each other were portrayed in a way that highlighted their dependence and shared secrets.
José Menendez was depicted as a successful but domineering figure. His ambitions and the pressure he placed on his family were explored to understand the dynamics within the household. The series tackled the allegations of abuse head-on, presenting different viewpoints and leaving it to the audience to ponder the truth. This added complexity to his character, making him more than just a one-dimensional antagonist.
The portrayal of Kitty Menendez focused on her emotional and psychological struggles. Her alleged complicity in the abuse, as well as her own challenges with mental health, were key elements that added depth to her character. The series highlighted Kitty’s complicated relationships with Lyle and Erik, showing moments of both affection and conflict.
By presenting these characters with their vulnerabilities, flaws, and emotional struggles, the series aimed to humanize them. This approach allowed viewers to see them as real people with complex motivations, rather than just the perpetrators or victims of a crime.
The series delved into the intricate family dynamics, showcasing the tensions, expectations, and unspoken rules that governed the Menendez household. This helped to paint a fuller picture of the environment in which Lyle and Erik grew up.
By focusing on these psychological and emotional aspects, the series provided a more nuanced and empathetic portrayal of the Menendez family, encouraging viewers to consider the complexities behind their actions. It’s a powerful reminder of the multifaceted nature of human behavior and the impact of family dynamics.
The lead actors played a crucial role in bringing depth and authenticity to the characters. Their performances were instrumental in conveying the complex emotions and psychological struggles of the Menendez family.
Cooper Koch portrayal of Lyle Menendez captured the intense emotions and psychological trauma of the character. His performance included moments of rage, fear, and vulnerability, providing a deep insight into Lyle’s state of mind. Koch’s chemistry with Nicholas Alexander Chavez, who played Erik Menendez, was pivotal in depicting the strong bond between the brothers.
“The script became the backbone of my prep because it was the backstory that I didn’t have to write for myself, for the character,” says Koch. “I read it daily, making thoughtful, inquisitive notes along the way. Even with all of the preparation, I was nervous about filming the episode but also very excited to be able to just exist as him for that long and to finally say these words that I had been reading and working on and making my own for such a long time. It was a beautiful experience — but also terrifying and exhilarating.”
Nicholas Alexander Chavez as Erik Menendez brought a sense of vulnerability and sensitivity to the role of Erik Menendez. His performance highlighted the emotional and psychological impact of the alleged abuse on Erik. Chavez effectively conveyed Erik’s internal struggle and conflicting emotions, making the character relatable and empathetic.
“When you’re playing a character like this, you want to remove as much judgment as you can and empathize as much as you can,” says Chavez. “That’s what I tried to do first and foremost… I wanted to come from as educated a perspective as I could, so I familiarized myself with plenty of primary and secondary sources as far as research material. I went through the Court TV footage quite a bit.
The script also helped Chavez to prepare for the role: “Ultimately, I understand that some of the behavior that he has in this show is difficult for people to digest, but my performance sits at the nexus of so many things. It sits at the nexus of the research I have done, the scripts I was given, the direction that I was given and the strong interpretation and point of view that I formed of this person who is, in my view, one of the most enigmatic human beings to have lived in the last 100 years.”
The actors worked closely with Ryan Murphy and the creative team to understand their characters’ motivations and backstories. This collaboration allowed them to deliver performances that were both authentic and deeply moving. They were encouraged to explore and delve into the psychological aspects of their characters, which helped in portraying them with authenticity and depth.
The actors underwent physical transformations to accurately represent their characters. This included changes in appearance, mannerisms, and speech patterns. They focused on delivering emotionally authentic performances that resonated with the viewers, making the characters’ experiences and struggles palpable. Through their dedication and nuanced performances, the lead actors brought the Menendez family to life on screen, contributing significantly to the series’ impact and success. Their portrayals allowed viewers to connect with the characters on a deeper level and understand the complexities of their actions and relationships.
The series was designed to present the story from multiple viewpoints, including those of the brothers, their parents, the legal teams, and the media.
This approach allowed for a more nuanced portrayal of the case and highlighted the complexities of the situation. Presenting the story from multiple viewpoints was a brilliant way to capture the complexities of the Menendez case.
By focusing on the Brothers’ Perspective, the series delved into their claims of abuse and their emotional and psychological states. This provided insight into their motivations and actions. The portrayal of the brothers’ bond and shared trauma highlighted their intense emotional connection and the impact of their upbringing on their mental health.
Exploring the parents’ perspective, their lives, personalities, and relationships with their sons, added depth to the narrative. It helped viewers understand the family dynamics and the environment in which the brothers grew up. By presenting different viewpoints on the abuse allegations, the series encouraged viewers to consider the complexity of the situation and the potential impact on the brothers.
The Legal Teams’ Perspective showcased the strategies and arguments of both the defense and prosecution provided a comprehensive view of the legal battle. This highlighted the intricacies of the trial and the different interpretations of the evidence. The series explored the ethical dilemmas faced by the legal teams, such as the challenges of defending clients accused of a heinous crime and the pursuit of justice.
By including the media’s role in the case, the series highlighted how the intense media coverage influenced public perception and added pressure to the legal proceedings. The portrayal of the media’s sensationalism and focus on salacious details underscored the impact of media scrutiny on the individuals involved and the broader narrative.
The inclusion of friends, acquaintances, and other characters provided further context and added layers to the story. Their insights and experiences helped paint a fuller picture of the Menendez family and the case. By weaving these perspectives together, the series created a rich and multi-dimensional narrative that allowed viewers to see the case from different angles. This approach not only made the story more engaging but also encouraged critical thinking about the complexities of the situation and the factors that influenced the outcome.
The exploration of the brothers’ sexuality and the notion that they were lovers is a controversial and sensitive aspect of the Menendez case.
The idea that Lyle and Erik Menendez might have been lovers stems from speculation and rumors that emerged during their trials. Some observers suggested that their close bond and shared trauma could have led to an incestuous relationship.
Various media portrayals, including documentaries and TV shows, have explored this theory to add drama and intrigue to the story. However, it’s important to note that these portrayals often take creative liberties and may not be entirely accurate. The defense team focused on the brothers’ claims of enduring years of abuse by their parents. The exploration of their sexuality was not a central part of the defense strategy, but it added another layer of complexity to the case.
The speculation about the brothers’ relationship contributed to the sensationalism surrounding the case. It influenced public perception and added to the media frenzy.The exploration of this theory raises ethical concerns about privacy and the potential for sensationalism. It’s important to approach such topics with sensitivity and respect for the individuals involved.
There is no concrete evidence to support the notion that Lyle and Erik were lovers. The theory remains speculative and should be viewed with caution.
While the exploration of the brothers’ sexuality adds a layer of intrigue to the Menendez case, it’s essential to remember that it is based on speculation and not proven facts. The focus should remain on the broader issues of abuse, family dynamics, and the criminal justice system.
The series aimed to capture the emotional depth and psychological struggles of the characters. Murphy worked closely with the actors to ensure their performances were authentic and resonated with viewers. This involved exploring the inner turmoil and conflicts faced by the characters, making their experiences relatable and compelling.
To capture the emotional depth and psychological struggles of the characters, Ryan Murphy and his team took a detailed and immersive approach. The actors immersed themselves in the characters’ backgrounds, motivations, and psychological states. They studied the real-life figures they were portraying, as well as the broader context of the case, to deliver authentic performances.
Murphy emphasized the importance of emotional authenticity. The actors were encouraged to tap into the raw emotions and inner turmoil of their characters. This involved exploring feelings of fear, anger, sadness, and desperation, making the characters’ experiences relatable and compelling.
Visual and Cinematic Techniques
Murphy employed various visual and cinematic techniques to create an immersive experience for viewers. This included carefully designed sets that accurately reflected the time period, as well as thoughtful cinematography that captured the emotional tone of the series. The use of lighting, camera angles, and color palettes helped to convey the mood and atmosphere of different scenes.
The use of different camera angles and movements helped convey the emotional tone of the scenes. Close-up shots captured the characters’ expressions and emotions, while wider shots provided context and setting. In some intense or emotional scenes, handheld cameras were used to create a sense of immediacy and rawness, making viewers feel as though they were part of the action.
The lighting was carefully designed to reflect the mood and atmosphere of each scene. Dim, shadowy lighting was used to create a sense of tension and unease, while brighter lighting highlighted moments of revelation or clarity. Contrasts between light and dark were used symbolically to represent themes such as innocence versus guilt, truth versus deception, and hope versus despair.
The sets were meticulously designed to accurately reflect the time period and settings of the real events. This included recreating the Menendez family home, courtrooms, and other significant locations. Props and set decorations were chosen to enhance the authenticity and immerse viewers in the story’s environment.
The color palette was carefully selected to enhance the thematic elements of the story. Muted and somber colors were often used to reflect the dark and tragic nature of the events, while occasional bursts of color highlighted moments of significance or contrast.
The editing helped control the pacing of the narrative, building tension and maintaining engagement. Quick cuts were used during intense moments, while slower, lingering shots allowed for emotional reflection.
Flashbacks and montages were used to provide backstory, contextualize events, and convey the passage of time. These techniques added depth to the storytelling and helped viewers understand the characters’ motivations.
Visual metaphors and symbolic imagery were used to convey deeper themes and messages. For example, certain objects or settings might represent the characters’ emotional states or the overarching themes of the story.
By employing these visual and cinematic techniques, Ryan Murphy and his team were able to create a rich and immersive experience that drew viewers into the complex world of the Menendez case. These elements combined to make the series both visually captivating and emotionally resonant.
Ryan Murphy is a prolific figure in the television industry, celebrated for creating groundbreaking and widely popular series. His impressive portfolio includes hits like:
- Glee, a musical comedy-drama that redefined the genre with its unique blend of humor, heart, and catchy musical numbers.
- American Horror Story, an anthology horror series that gained a cult following for its chilling storytelling and versatile cast.
- The Watcher, a mystery-thriller that showcases Murphy’s knack for suspense and gripping narratives.
Murphy’s ability to tackle a wide range of genres, from musical to horror to thriller, has made him a standout creator in the world of TV.
Ian Brennan is a key collaborator with Murphy, having co-created Glee with him. Brennan’s contributions were instrumental in shaping the show’s distinct tone and success. In addition to “Glee,” Brennan has worked on other projects, often in collaboration with Murphy, bringing his unique voice and creativity to the table. Together, Murphy and Brennan have proven to be a dynamic duo, consistently delivering compelling and innovative content that captivates audiences.
“
This is a dream come true I am so grateful for all the amazing people in my life that came along on this journey with me.”
